Is Evolution Observable?

Contrary to popular belief, science extends far beyond controlled experiments conducted in laboratories. It encompasses a broad spectrum of methods for gathering evidence from the natural world and making inferences about how things operate. Physicists may not be able to zoom in on atoms, astronomers can’t physically reach the stars, and geologists can’t travel back in time. Yet, through multiple lines of evidence, scientists can make valid and useful inferences about their subjects of study. Evolutionary biology, in particular, benefits from this approach, as it does not solely rely on direct observation of evolutionary processes.

In 1971, a remarkable evolutionary experiment began with ten Italian wall lizards, five males and five females, relocated from Pod Kopiste to Pod Mrcaru. These lizards were chosen for their short generation times—males reach maturity in one year, and females in one to two years. The Croatian War of Independence in 1991 interrupted the experiment, but by 2004, scientists discovered significant evolutionary changes in the lizards’ descendants:

• New muscles developed between the large and small intestines to slow down food digestion.
• An expansion of the gut to process a plant-heavy diet.
• A transformation in head shape, becoming longer and wider, to better consume their new food sources.

The observability of evolution depends on the complexity of the species and the length of their generation time. While the evolution of Italian wall lizards, with their relatively simple biology and short generation times, can be observed within a human lifespan, the same cannot be said for all species. For instance, the timeline of life on Earth spans billions of years:

• Life emerged around 3700 million years ago.
• Multicellular organisms appeared 600 million years ago.
• Amphibians evolved 370 million years ago.
• Mammals arose 210 million years ago.
• Apes developed 50 million years ago.
• Humans originated 2 million years ago.
• Modern humans emerged 0.2-0.3 million years ago.

No one was present to witness these vast evolutionary changes, yet through scientific evidence, we understand a great deal about our ancestors.

Evolutionary biologists are akin to detectives arriving at a crime scene without eyewitnesses. They rely on scientific records of past behavior—matching fingerprints or DNA, analyzing bloodstain patterns—to solve the mystery. Similarly, to understand the diversity of species on Earth, evolutionary biologists use anatomy, DNA, shared genetic codes, fossils, and direct observations of other species’ evolution.

While we cannot directly observe the full breadth of evolutionary history, we can study its principles through both laboratory observations and natural experiments. For instance, bacteria, with their rapid generation times, offer a window into evolutionary processes. In a controlled environment, we can witness a single-celled organism multiply, maintaining its original DNA. Over time, however, we can observe the emergence of new organisms with minor DNA differences. These variations accumulate, leading to distinct groups with significant genetic divergence.

Model organisms like the Italian wall lizard and bacteria are invaluable in evolutionary studies. They allow us to observe evolutionary changes over shorter timescales, providing insights that can be extrapolated to understand longer evolutionary processes. This approach is not just about convenience; it’s a necessity for practical and efficient scientific inquiry.

Understanding evolution does not have to conflict with religious beliefs. Many people find ways to integrate scientific knowledge with their faith, seeing evolution as a process that could be part of a divine plan. The key is to respect the evidence presented by science while appreciating the moral and spiritual guidance offered by religion.

The study of evolution, like all science, is a multifaceted endeavor that combines observations, experiments, and theoretical work to build a comprehensive understanding of life’s diversity. By embracing both the observable and the inferred aspects of evolution, we can appreciate the depth and complexity of this fundamental biological process.

#EvolutionInAction, #WallLizardStudy, #ScienceFaithDialogue